Best Eyeliner For Sensitive Eyelids

A flawless eyeliner look can easily make you look gorgeous but what about all the damage to the skin? Some eyeliners contain harsh chemicals that either cause irritation when applied or end up irritating the skin when you take them off. When you have sensitive eyelids, you need the right makeup that doesn’t harm your skin further. Not all types of eyeliner are good for sensitive skin. To choose the right eyeliner for your eyes, here is what you need to look for in an eyeliner when buying one.

What To Look For When Buying An Eyeliner

No Toxic Ingredients

Eyeliners can contain parabens, formaldehyde, and other chemicals that can be minimally toxic. When choosing eyeliners, look for the one that has the most natural and non-toxic materials.

Prefer Lightweight Eyeliners

Lightweight eyeliners are usually water-based and they don’t feel heavy on your eyelids therefore they are the best eyeliner for sensitive eyelids.

Smudge-Proof Eyeliner

Smudge-proof eyeliners don’t smudge easily and have a formula that doesn’t budge or smear easily. Smudge-proof eyeliners are expensive and high-quality designed to stay in place. When your liner will stay in its place, you won’t have to fix it, again and again, mean less irritating the eyes.

Avoid Waterproof Eyeliners

Waterproof eyeliners can be removed easily with a cotton swab with some micellar water or cleanser on it but it will take some time and you’ll have to rub your eyelids a few extra times. A non-waterproof mascara on the other hand will come off easily with one or two dabs of cotton with micellar water.

Although micellar water can also irritate if your skin is already affected, it is advisable to use coconut oil if your skin reacts to other products. Coconut oil lightly moisturizes the skin and doesn’t irritate even when you rub cotton swabs with coconut oil repeatedly.

11 Best Eyeliners For Sensitive Eyelids

1. Maybelline New York Master Precise All Day Liquid Liner

The Maybelline New York Precise All Day Liquid Eyeliner is a no-smudge liquid eyeliner that can help you get the perfect eyeliner wing every time. It has intense color and is super pigmented for a dramatic all-day-long look. The formula is very mild and it’s not heavy for your eyelids. Also, it doesn’t dry out your eyes so you can feel flawless and comfortable. The pen-shaped liquid liner has a very smooth flow for drawing even the most difficult shapes with great ease, undoubtedly the best eyeliner for sensitive eyelids. It is one of the best eyeliner for sensitive eyelids as it is also quick-drying, and takes a minute or two to dry, after that it stays in place for hours.

2. Stila Smudge Stick Waterproof Eyeliner

This best eyeliner for sensitive eyelids from Stila comes in 8 different shades and all of them are goals. You can go with a classic black eyeliner or choose a different color for a bold or trendy look. The tip is very flexible and can draw flawlessly. The smudge-proof eyeliner is a must-have and one of the best eyeliners for sensitive eyelids. It is a thin pencil eyeliner that can also be carried easily in your bag when traveling.

It is also suitable for women who wear contacts because it doesn’t make your eyes teary. A plus point of this best eyeliner for sensitive eyelids is that it doesn’t fade when the weather is humid like most eyeliners. You can use it to create any eye makeup look you want. It comes off easily so you don’t have to rub too much or irritate the eyes while removing the eyeliner.

3. Better’n Ur Eyes Natural Eyeliner Pencil

Better’n Ur Eyes Natural eyeliner pencil is perfect for creating a dramatic look. It can be used to add depth to your lower lash line and outer corner of the eye. It doesn’t irritate the eyes and at times you’ll forget you’re wearing eyeliner. The formula is super pigmented and doesn’t dry out the eyes. It can easily last for up to 4-5 hours and is composed of natural and healing oils that nourish your skin. It contains castor oil that most types of eyeliner don’t. Castor oil boosts the regeneration of eyelashes and thickens them. For sensitive eyelids and eyes, this is the pencil type best eyeliner for sensitive eyelids that you can grab.

4. Revlon ColorStay Skinny Liquid Eyeliner

This is another ultra-fine tipped eyeliner that is tested by ophthalmologists and is safe for sensitive eyes. It has a thin brush for fine applications and is highly pigmented. One coat can give you a deep black eyeliner look. The lightweight formula feels great and doesn’t tighten or dry out your eyelids at all. It is hands down the best eyeliner for sensitive eyelids and a must-have for women who like to apply a thin coat just along the lashes every day for a no-makeup makeup look or have hooded eyes.

5. NYX Professional Makeup Vinyl Liquid Liner

In the list of fine-tipped liquid best eyeliner for sensitive eyelids, how can we not include NYX professional liquid liners? Not all types of eyeliner are good for sensitive skin therefore choose an NYX super-pigmented eyeliner. The pigmented bold eye makeup look is achievable with this NYX professional Vinyl liquid liner. Either you’re creating a smokey eye or a cat-eye look, it never fails to amaze what you can create with an NYX professional liquid liner.

Products from NYX are also cruelty-free so you can rest assured that you are using and supporting brands that value lives.

6. L’Oreal Paris Infallible Lacquer Eyeliner

L’Oreal Paris is a favorite of most women for two main reasons, they offer high-quality products and the prices are very affordable. You can buy skin-friendly and cruelty-free products from L’Oreal even when you are on a budget. The brush comes separate from the liner cake so it can be cleaned regularly. The color is very bold and the eyeliner can be applied mess-free. So, buy this best eyeliner for sensitive eyelids if you want to buy a high-quality product that is super-affordable.

7. Lovoir Winged Eyeliner Stamp

Lovoir Winged Eyeliner Stamp is also one of the best eyeliner for sensitive eyelids as it is totally mess-free and has a lightweight, vegan formula. The natural and plant-based oils protect your skin from damage and ensure a flawless makeup look with a highly pigmented color.

If you have trouble nailing the perfect wing eyeliner, this one is a must-have because the wing stamp never disappoints. With one stamp, it leaves a perfect coat of black. So, if you have shaky hands but you happen to be a fan of winged stamp eyeliners, this eyeliner is light, easy, and incredibly pigmented. And a must-buy for you!

8. La Pure Waterproof Eyeliner Stamp

Since we started discussing the stamp eyeliners, here’s another stamp eyeliner that can be applied on sensitive eyelids without irritating. To create a masterpiece, all you need is a La Pure Eyeliner Stamp. It can turn you into an Egyptian goddess or create a fun foxy look for a day out with friends.

The formula has all-natural ingredients and vitamins that take care of your eyelids and are not harsh or too drying for the skin. It is also parabens and fragrance-free so you get maximum protection from irritation using one of the best eyeliner for sensitive eyelids from La Pure.

9. Maybelline New York Makeup Eyestudio Lasting Drama Gel Eye Liner

The best eyeliner for sensitive eyelids is the one that doesn’t cause any allergies and is composed of a skin-safe formula. Maybelline Gel Eyeliner has been tested by allergists, ophthalmologists, and dermatologists who agree that the Maybelline New York Makeup Eyestudio Lasting Drama Gel Eye Liner is indeed safe for sensitive skin. It doesn’t make your eyes teary and contains allergy-free ingredients to avoid eye infections.

The creamy gel formula can last you a year. It comes with a separate eye brush for easy cleaning and adjusting the amount of gel eyeliner for application.

10. Honest Beauty Liquid Eyeliner

Honest Beauty produces amazing quality products that are free from most of the toxic ingredients used in makeup products. The Honest Beauty Liquid Eyeliner is free of silicone, parabens, carbon-black, and many other such chemicals. Honest Beauty is a cruelty-free brand that contains natural and plant-based ingredients only. It is perfect for use if you have sensitive eyelids. The liquid and natural ingredients make it the best eyeliner for sensitive eyelids but a great choice for most skin types.

11. Neutrogena Precision Liquid Eyeliner

Neutrogena Precision Liquid Eyeliner contains coconut and honey that nourish your skin and can be worn every day. For eyelids that are prone to irritation and dryness, this one works like magic. The hypoallergenic liquid eyeliners are the best eyeliner for sensitive eyelids as recommended by dermatologists. The formula gives you a clear and defined look that is easy to create with the fine-tip brush.

Tips For Applying Eyeliner On Different Eye Shapes

Now that we have covered the best eyeliner for sensitive eyelids topic, let’s move on to the correct way to apply eyeliner for different eye shapes.

Eyeliner For Hooded Eyes

You might have heard that it is difficult to put makeup on hooded eyes but trust us it isn’t that tricky. Once you get a hang of how-to put-on eyeliner, you’ll be able to create amazing looks with little or no effort. You can use liquid, and pencil eyeliner for hooded eyes. Avoid using a gel eyeliner or a water activated eyeliner. When choosing an eyeliner for hooded eyes, make sure that it is smudge-proof.

Here is a tutorial of eyeliner for hooded eyes that can easily create a stunning eyeliner look. It is so easy that even beginners can try it. Use a fine-tipped eyeliner to draw a very small wing on the outer eye corner. Then bring the eyeliner brush towards the center and draw closely along the lash line to match the wing. Dark eyeshadows and dark eyeliners work best for hooded eyes as they make the eyes look bigger by concealing the hoodedness.

A great challenge with hooded eyes is that you cannot create a crease. So, apply the eyeshadow a little lower from your brow bone, covering most of your eyelid. A great way to add depth to your eyes is to line your upper waterline with a dark-colored eye pencil as well.

Avoid a thick eyeliner and keep it close to the lash line. A thin eyeliner doesn’t interfere with the hood of our eyes and looks fabulous.

Eyeliner For Almond Eyes

To brighten up and widen an almond eye, it is recommended to highlight the inner corners of your eyes. The makeup artists recommend also using a nude or white eyeliner pencil on the waterline. Cat-eye look was created for almond eyes as they look flawless on eyes that are wide such as almond-shaped eyes.

You can choose any eyeliner you like. A great eyeliner for almond eyes is a liquid eyeliner, water activated eyeliner, or gel eyeliner. You can draw a long wing, add a solid coat along the upper lash line and draw a tip on the inner corner as well. Winged eyeliner looks are also great as well as smokey eyes or cut creases where your eyeliner just stands out.

Don’t forget to highlight the inner corner of your eyes by tapping some white or silverish eyeshadow. Floating eyeliner for almond eyes can also help you nail an amazing evening or day look. Don’t forget to be a little extra when you are putting eyeliner on almond eyes as you can rock almost any eyeliner look with them.

Eyeliner For Round Eyes

Like almond eyes, round eyes can also look stunning with most types of eyeliner looks. To enhance the roundness and add more depth to the eyes, you can draw a thick line in the center attached to your upper lash line. If you want to lift your eyes and create a dramatic look, apply some eyeliner or gel eyeliner pencil on the outer corner.

Water activated eyeliner and gel eyeliner for round eyes are the best, it is also great if you have sensitive eyes that dry out quickly. For lengthening the shape of the eyes, you can choose to draw a cat eyeliner look. Most eyeliner looks can go with round eyes. If you are trying a simple and sophisticated look, a small wing on the outer eye corner can also look great.

Add a few coats to make sure that the eyeliner is jet black and doesn’t look greyish especially when you are applying a thick coat of eyeliner for round eyes.